Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Ordering Whole Cakes

You asked (a lot) and we heard you ... We now take orders for full cakes!!

Currently you can call to your place your order through our Takeout and Curbside bar, call us at 414-277-1111 and just select option #1. We do require a 48 hour notice for full cake orders. Make sure you specify whether you would like the cake sliced or unsliced.

Carrot Cake $85

10" Carrot Cake is typically cut to 16 slices

Chocolate Fudge Cake $85

10" Chocolate Fudge Cake is typically cut to 16 slices

Key Lime Pie $65

9" Key Lime Pie is typically cut to 10 slices

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake $75

9" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake is typically cut to 12 slices

For all questions and inquiries, email us at

About The Pastry Kitchen

The Pastry Kitchen is where all the magic happens. The near constant aromas of sugar and spice wafting out of this space will tell you all you need to know about the popularity of Pam’s desserts. When the space is not in use for creating the amazing desserts we serve at Buckley’s it can be booked for private events. For information regarding booking a private event in the pastry kitchen please follow the link to the private events page.

View Menu

Click below for our dessert menu.

View Menu